1 John 5:20

Does 1 John 5:20 call Jesus the true God?

We know also that the Son of God has come and has given us understanding, so that we may know him who is true. And we are in him who is true by being in his Son Jesus Christ. He is the true God and eternal life.

Read this part slowly:

“And we are in him who is true by being in his Son Jesus Christ.”

The true one mentioned in this verse, has to be the Father. Why?

Because it clearly says, We are in HIM who is true, by being in HIS son.

Who is the son mentioned here? It is Jesus Christ.

Who is the one who is true that has a son? Well that has to be the Father because Jesus never had a son did he? If you hold the view that Jesus is the one true God in this verse, then you have to conclude that Jesus has a son called Jesus because the one who is true has a son called Jesus according to the verse.

So by this very simple, clear, and reasonable reading of the text, we can see that the Father is the one who is true and we are in the Father because we are in HIS son. That is the only way you can read this verse.

Do you need further proof? Well look at John 17:3:
Now this is eternal life: that they may know you, the only true God, and Jesus Christ, whom you have sent.

As you can see, the only true God is not Jesus Christ here either because the only true God is said to have sent Jesus Christ just like 1 John 5:20 says.

The next verse supports these two preceding verses and teaches that Jesus is not God, rather, that he was sent by God as confirmed in these two verses above.

John 8:42
Jesus said to them, “If God were your Father, you would love me, for I came from God and now am here. I have not come on my own; but he sent me.

You have just been shown two or three witness verses that clearly state that God sent his son into the world and that this God who has a son is the only true God.

← Go back to ‘Supporting the Trinity Doctrine‘.


Discussion

Viewing 20 posts - 81 through 100 (of 1,982 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #283610
    kerwin
    Participant

    Quote (jammin @ Mar. 08 2012,10:45)
    doctor kerwin,

    when will you publish your own version?


    Jammin,

    What do your words have to do with our discussion?

    #283616
    jammin
    Participant

    you give a doctored version of YLT

    that is just your words. that is not written in the bible.
    so i am asking you,
    when will you publish your doctored YLT?

    #283620
    kerwin
    Participant

    Quote (jammin @ Mar. 08 2012,10:12)
    that is your opinion. but i cant read in the verse that john says that Christ is not the true GOD.

    it is very clear that it refers to Christ.

    as i have said, no verse in the bible that Christ is not called the true GOD. those false teachers are just dreaming.

    what we can read is Christ is also called the true GOD

    btw, you did not say that you are a doctor by profession.

    let me post your doctored YLT
    you said
    this one(Yawheh) is the true God and the life age-during!

    when will you publish your doctored YLT???

    this is what the true YLT said in verse 20
    20 in His Son Jesus Christ; this one is the true God and the life age-during!

    see the difference?? there is no yahweh in the last sentence.
    it says THIS ONE IS THE TRUE GOD.. AND NOT THIS ONE (YAHWEH) IS THE TRUE GOD ETC..

    TSK TSK…bad kerwin..

    you are really a false teacher.

    make your own version,
    better luck next time.


    Jammin,

    Do you really lack the knowledge that brackets contain comments?

    My comments demonstrated how I understood the use of pronouns in 1 John 5:19-20.

    Ed J already demonstrated the same idea you find hard to understand is also written John 17:3.

    #283623
    jammin
    Participant

    therefore it is just your opinion and you cant really read that in 1 john 5.20

    the verse said that christ is also called the true GOD.

    better luck next time mr dream boy.

    #283667
    kerwin
    Participant

    Quote (jammin @ Mar. 08 2012,11:07)
    therefore it is just your opinion and you cant really read that in 1 john 5.20

    the verse said that christ is also called the true GOD.

    better luck next time mr dream boy.


    Jammin,

    It is English.  I am either correct or incorrect.  You probably do not have the knowledge to determine which.  

    I do know that commas separate the elements of a simple list.  In a complex list the elements of the list are separated by semi colons and commas are used to separate the internal elements.  So the semi colon use in 1 John 5:19-20 indicates a slight break.  

    Here is an example of a slight break.

    Quote
    No one was seriously hurt in the accident; one boy broke his finger.

    Here and here are my sources.

    #283668
    jammin
    Participant

    your sentence is different with 1 john 5.20

    pls read your sentence carefully.

    here is an exmple,

    the apple is green. it is so delicious.

    what is so delicious?

    read 1 john 5.20 very well bec you are wrong with your opinion.

    if you insist, read in 1 john 5.20 that john says that christ is not the true GOD

    make your own version kerwn

    #283669
    jammin
    Participant

    btw, you are still not answering my question
    when will you publish your own version?

    the next time you doctored the version, make sure that it's not obvious

    better luck next time

    #283690
    Wakeup
    Participant

    Quote (jammin @ Mar. 08 2012,20:04)
    btw, you are still not answering my question
    when will you publish your own version?

    the next time you doctored the version, make sure that it's not obvious

    better luck next time


    Hi Jammin.

    This is a very hard question,and imposible to explain unless the Holy spirit is given.
    Jesus said it himself,in luke 10:22.NO MAN KNOWS WHO THE SON IS BUT THE FATHER: AND WHO THE FATHER IS,BUT THE SON AND WHOM THE SON WILL REVEAL HIM.
    So only when the son will reveal it to a person,THEN HE CAN UNDERSTAND.

    wakeup.

    #283723
    kerwin
    Participant

    Quote (jammin @ Mar. 08 2012,14:55)
    your sentence is different with 1 john 5.20

    pls read your sentence carefully.

    here is an exmple,

    the apple is green. it is so delicious.

    what is so delicious?

    read 1 john 5.20 very well bec you are wrong with your opinion.

    if you insist, read in 1 john 5.20 that john says that christ is not the true GOD

    make your own version kerwn


    Jammin,

    As I stated earlier pronoun use is tricky.  From what I learned from the semi colon source what you suggest sounds like a complex list.  In the case of a complex list semi colons separate the elements of the list while commas are within the elements.

    Here is a breakdown of the sentence in 1 John 5:18-20 as written in the YLT.

    First element: We have known that every one who hath been begotten of God doth not sin, but he who was begotten of God doth keep himself, and the evil one doth not touch him;

    Second element:we have known that of God we are, and the whole world in the evil doth lie;

    Third  element: and we have known that the Son of God is come, and hath given us a mind, that we may know Him who is true, and we are in Him who is true, in His Son Jesus Christ;

    Forth element: this one is the true God and the life age-during!

    The Young's Literal Translation clearly translates “this one is the true God and the life age-during! ” as the final bullet in a list.

    #283825
    jammin
    Participant

    kerwin,

    that is just your opinion about 1 john 5.20

    Christ is also called the true GOD in 1 john 5.20

    make your own version kerwin

    better luck next time

    #283826
    jammin
    Participant

    Quote (Wakeup @ Mar. 09 2012,02:06)

    Quote (jammin @ Mar. 08 2012,20:04)
    btw, you are still not answering my question
    when will you publish your own version?

    the next time you doctored the version, make sure that it's not obvious

    better luck next time


    Hi Jammin.

    This is a very hard question,and imposible to explain unless the Holy spirit is given.
    Jesus said it himself,in luke 10:22.NO MAN KNOWS WHO THE SON IS BUT THE FATHER: AND WHO THE FATHER IS,BUT THE SON AND WHOM THE SON WILL REVEAL HIM.
    So only when the son will reveal it to a person,THEN HE CAN UNDERSTAND.

    wakeup.


    yes it is true

    that is why you need to read the verse well and of course you need to pray that may GOD revealed to you the true knowledge about him.

    bec this is the eternal life.

    the father and the son have the same nature, GOD!
    the father is truly GOD,
    the son is truly GOD!

    #283827
    NickHassan
    Participant

    Hi Jammin,
    And you can share the divine nature in the Son

    #283833
    jammin
    Participant

    Quote (Nick Hassan @ Mar. 09 2012,13:01)
    Hi Jammin,
    And you can share the divine nature in the Son


    i still have question for you about this.

    do you have the nature of GOD or YOU CAN SHARE HIS NATURE???

    be ashamed of yourself for not answering my question.

    go back to your professor and study hard mr dream boy

    #283835
    NickHassan
    Participant

    Hi Jammin,
    Jesus the man was given a share in God's Spirit nature and so too can we receive the blessing.

    #283836
    NickHassan
    Participant

    Hi Jammin,
    We can follow a man but not GOD.

    #283838
    jammin
    Participant

    answer the question first

    do not explain.

    if you are a fool, do not make people fool

    #283841
    NickHassan
    Participant

    Hi Jammin,
    Read the answer given.

    #283845
    jammin
    Participant

    ill repeat the question

    you may ask for help

    do you have the nature of GOD or YOU CAN SHARE HIS NATURE???

    #283846
    NickHassan
    Participant

    Hi Jammin,
    Just as Jesus Christ shares his Father's nature so can we.

    #283847
    kerwin
    Participant

    Quote (jammin @ Mar. 09 2012,07:57)
    kerwin,

    that is just your opinion about 1 john 5.20

    Christ is also called the true GOD in 1 john 5.20

    make your own version kerwin

    better luck next time


    Jammin,

    :D

    Do you tell your English Teachers that is their opinion when they seek to teach you correct English use?

    Did you actually spot an flaw in what I stated? If so then speak up.

Viewing 20 posts - 81 through 100 (of 1,982 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

© 1999 - 2024 Heaven Net

Navigation

© 1999 - 2023 - Heaven Net
or

Log in with your credentials

or    

Forgot your details?

or

Create Account