@lightenup
Lightenup replied to the topic The Trinity Doctrine is an unnecessary stumbling block in the forum Truth or Tradition 9 years, 8 months ago
Hi again,
you said to t8:
Oops! t8 overlooked that the Greek “kurios” (lord) is the Greek equivalent of the Hebrew YHWH.
I am wondering if kurios is always used for either the Father or the Son in scripture. Do you know?
Lightenup replied to the topic The Trinity Doctrine is an unnecessary stumbling block in the forum Truth or Tradition 9 years, 8 months ago
Hi again,
you said to t8:
Oops! t8 overlooked that the Greek “kurios” (lord) is the Greek equivalent of the Hebrew YHWH.
I am wondering if kurios is always used for either the Father or the Son in scripture. Do you know?
Lightenup replied to the topic The Trinity Doctrine is an unnecessary stumbling block in the forum Truth or Tradition 9 years, 8 months ago
Hello Jack, nice picture!
you said:
If the Father of Jesus is a father to him in the sense you say, then the Father MUST also have a father. Who would that be Kathi?
Why would you think that? Do you not agree that when someone is a begotten son, the default meaning would involve the bringing forth a true offspring? I understand there a…
Lightenup replied to the topic Proclaimer vs Lightenup in the forum Debates 9 years, 8 months ago
you said:
I believe that he was begotten by God as the first to be with him.
I agree. What I have tried to explain to you recently is that he must have already existed in some manner in order to have been begotten. This is my belief…a thing has to exist before it can be begotten. Would you agree with that?
Lightenup replied to the topic Proclaimer vs Lightenup in the forum Debates 9 years, 8 months ago
t8, you asked:
Does this not mean to you that he was the son of God at that point and possibly earlier?
Yes, that is why I questioned you because you had in the past been claiming belief that He was the son even before creation. That comment did not have much faith behind it, just that it was “possible.”
It is by faith in what I experienced and…[Read more]
Lightenup replied to the topic Proclaimer vs Lightenup in the forum Debates 9 years, 8 months ago
So you don’t deny that he may have been a son before creation, you just don’t think that scripture can alone, make that clear.
I’m sure that we lack so much in reading the Bible without the understanding of the Hebrews of the day. I do believe that they had the “Word of YHVH” in mind when John wrote John 1:1. Their understanding of the “Word of…[Read more]
Lightenup replied to the topic Proclaimer vs Lightenup in the forum Debates 9 years, 8 months ago
That’s my point. That is why I asked. It was a reasonable follow up question to your comment, not something that should be called ‘desperate’ by any means. Thank you for clarifying that you aren’t sure if you believe that He was a son before creation.
Lightenup replied to the topic Proclaimer vs Lightenup in the forum Debates 9 years, 8 months ago
My comment was not desperate, it was in response to your comment here (particularly what I made bold)
The Word was with God in the beginning. The Word became flesh and was called Jesus. He was born the messiah, savior, and Lord. He was the son of God at his birth in a manger. So he was the son at this point in the least.
It was because you…[Read more]
Lightenup replied to the topic The Trinity Doctrine is an unnecessary stumbling block in the forum Truth or Tradition 9 years, 8 months ago
t8,
Rolling my eyes here…It is obvious by your statement of what you think I believe, that you do not take me seriously if you think that I teach that Jesus is God the Father. I have never taught that. You do not understand the term ‘unity.’
For some reason you cannot seem to grasp the idea of an eternal father having within him an offspring…[Read more]
Lightenup replied to the topic Proclaimer vs Lightenup in the forum Debates 9 years, 8 months ago
So, now are you saying that Jesus was not a “son” when He was the Word of the LORD in the OT? I disagree. I believe that the one who called Himself the “Word of the LORD” was the true Son and existed before creation. Later that Word who was “with” God in the beginning and “was” God, did not consider this form “of God” something to be…[Read more]
Lightenup replied to the topic The Trinity Doctrine is an unnecessary stumbling block in the forum Truth or Tradition 9 years, 8 months ago
Not confused. LORD is a name that is used for the name YHVH, and that LORD is God of gods and Lord of lords. We have one Lord of lords and that is Jesus, we have one God of gods and that is the Father. YHVH is both God of gods and Lord of lords, two entities in unity…a father and a son.
Jesus always was YHVH with the Father, and that…[Read more]
Lightenup replied to the topic The Trinity Doctrine is an unnecessary stumbling block in the forum Truth or Tradition 9 years, 8 months ago
Jael,
All other sons were not begotten, they were created, they are not the same type as the Father , just one son is…Jesus.
Lightenup replied to the topic The Trinity Doctrine is an unnecessary stumbling block in the forum Truth or Tradition 9 years, 8 months ago
you asked:
Oh, to the supporter of ‘beget’ doesn’t mean ‘beget’…To the implier that beget implies something already existing:
Were Cain and Abel already existing when Adam begat them?
Beget does mean beget. Adam took part in the conception of Cain and Able. Before that conception, they did not exist. From the moment of conception,…[Read more]
Lightenup replied to the topic The Trinity Doctrine is an unnecessary stumbling block in the forum Truth or Tradition 9 years, 8 months ago
t8
I agree with Paul who tells us our God and our Lord are two entities, Father and Son. 1 Cor 8:6
Unless you believe that YHVH is not both God and Lord, then you will too come to understand that the Father and the Son are both YHVH in unity.
Jesus is the only son ontologically. We will never be. We are adopted. It is like saying that Jesus is…[Read more]
Lightenup replied to the topic The Trinity Doctrine is an unnecessary stumbling block in the forum Truth or Tradition 9 years, 8 months ago
Gene,
We agree that we bow our knee to Jesus and call Him Lord to the glory of God his Father. What we don’t agree on is that YHVH is both God and Lord-two entities. Christians recognize that YHVH is both Father and Son-two entities. YHVH is one, a unity of two entities. Their Holy Spirit is their spirit that is united and extends from them while…[Read more]
Lightenup replied to the topic The Trinity Doctrine is an unnecessary stumbling block in the forum Truth or Tradition 9 years, 8 months ago
Hi Jael,
Did you realize that ontology has to do with the nature of a being and not their gender or their office?
The son of a human type of being would be another human type of being
The son of a particular animal, lets say a horse for example, would be another horse…and so on.
Jesus is clearly identified as the only begotten Son of…[Read more]
Lightenup replied to the topic Proclaimer vs Lightenup in the forum Debates 9 years, 9 months ago
It has been almost a month since I posted my response to your post. Are you beginning to understand that you don’t have sufficient arguments to support your opinion that the Son wasn’t eternal in the past?
Lightenup replied to the topic The Trinity Doctrine is an unnecessary stumbling block in the forum Truth or Tradition 9 years, 9 months ago
Do you plan on changing body type after you die and go on to everlasting life? Specifically, you have an earthly body now, are you hoping to have a heavenly body someday which is different than the one you have now? If so, how will it be different?
Lightenup replied to the topic The Trinity Doctrine is an unnecessary stumbling block in the forum Truth or Tradition 9 years, 9 months ago
The spirit and soul of the Son is what would have taken on flesh. The spirit and soul had always existed, imo.
Lightenup replied to the topic The Trinity Doctrine is an unnecessary stumbling block in the forum Truth or Tradition 9 years, 9 months ago
you said:
God raised HIS SERVANT according to Acts 3.
Does this fit with your two god theory?
Absolutely!
- Load More

