Hi KW,

When John saw the Spirit descending

was the Spirit descending?

Hi Andrew,

Are you speaking of the man Jesus of Nazareth?

Hi Andrew,

So God has no son but is His own son?

Hi  Andrew,

Priests serve God.

God is not a priest unto Himself

Hi KW,

Did John see the Spirit descending from heaven like a dove?

Or did he just see a video?

Hi KW,

Can you show any similar delayed signs of previous events in scripture?

It says he SAW THE SPIRIT DESCENDING.

Sounds current.

Hi KW,

So you think it was to signify what had happened earlier and it was not a current event?

A fine theory but unlikely.

Hi KW,

So is it written that it was ONLY as a sign to John as you teach?

Where are the FRUITS OF THE SPIRIT, as specified in Gal 5 shown before the Jordan?

AFTER the Jordan it says he was FILLED WITH THE SPIRIT

Hi KW,

Jesus was born of woman, born under the law.

Or is scripture not true?

Hi KW,

So Jesus the man was a slave of Sin?

Or somehow given an advantage over other men?

Hi KW,

So it is OK for you to add your own ideas to what scripture tells us happened at the Jordan.

And you think your additions are equally valid?

Hi KW,

Jesus IS the fulfilment of the Law.

He justified the Law.

Made clean he was fit for the anointing from above.

Hi KW,

Or are you saying he fulfilled the law but to do so he must have had some special anointing because it was otherwise impossible?

yet only logic is your evidence and pretty useless evidence

Hi KW,

So you claim obedience to the Law cannot stop men sinning?

Does scripture say that Jesus failed in this regard?

Hi KW,

Jesus lived BY THE FRUIT OF THE LAW?

Please quote me more accurately

Hi KW,

THE FRUIT OF THE LAW?

Please quote me more accurately

Hi ED,

You cannot become a natural son as he was.

Surely you have followed him and become a spiritual son too?

Hi ED,

Yes a natural son by conception and a spiritual son by anointing with the Holy Spirit at the Jordan.

Hi KW,

So what is reported from the Jordan is not true.

The Holy Spirit did not come down on him as he was already anointed?

Hi KW,

Logic without scriptural proof is a vanity.